I have nothing significant to add to the debate (?) and the serious comments by bloggers I read regularly (Newshoggers, War in Context, A Tiny Revolution, Dennis Perrin, etc. etc. ...) about the torture memorandums recently released by President Obama before he headed South, but I do wonder somethings.
Mainly I wonder, why the USA would have chosen torture, we now know it did for certain, as a secret but official government policy?
Darius Rejali, in the introduction of his encyclopedic work* Torture and Democracy, says there are three main purposes for government torture: "to intimidate, to coerce false information, and to gather accurate security information".
Posing then, that haunting question: "But do these techniques work?", for their intended purpose.
I suspect, as does Rejali, that most would agree the first 2 reasons work for their intended purpose, i.e. torturing an individual will frighten the individual and can also be an efficient method for collecting false information, such as confessions for "show" trials say.
But does torture work to gather accurate security information?
Setting aside the first 2 reasons, past US government policy indicates that the answer for it, to the question above, was yes. The US government believed - some parts of the current US government maybe still do believe - that torturing an individual can result in accurate security information.
The 2 Michaels, Hayden and Mukasey, must believe it works. Why else their op-ed piece. [I'm suppressing my skeptical inclination to consider it as a preemptive defense for their involvement, either actively or passively, in the government policy; or, of course, maybe as an attempt to cover their embarrassement with being publicly exposed as liars extraordinaire.]
So, as Rejadi tongue-in-cheek wonders, where is the General Accounting Office report that compares the results of the US torture program to the usual mundane intelligence activities in gathering accurate security information to foil terrorist activity.
Yes where is it?
As I said I'm wondering.
_______________________
*I was lucky enough to receive Rejali's book as a present this past Christmas, not festive season reading maybe, but interesting and a useful reference book for the future. Segments of the book are available online at Google Book. I recommend, if nothing else, reading the Introduction or at least checking out the Table of Contents. Chapter 24, the last in the book is available though it doesn't appear in the TOC.
Technorati Tags: books, sadism, Security, The Program, Torture, Torture vs good intentions